Cancer Methoselioma

 

cancer methoselioma  

 

Bereaved families have been seeking recompense for years while insurers squabble over liability. This week, the Appeal Court is due to rule

 

By Emily Dugan

 

 

 

Thousands of families bereaved by the asbestos cancer mesothelioma will discover this week whether insurance companies will compensate them for the deaths of their loved ones. The Court of Appeal will rule in a test case on Friday if insurers must pay out on company policies that existed when people were exposed to the deadly dust.

 

An estimated 6,000 families of victims have been waiting for compensation for more than five years while insurers squabble over whether claims can date back to the moment a person is exposed to asbestos, or the moment they develop the disease from it – which can be up to 50 years later.

 

Mesothelioma sufferers – or, in the majority of cases, their surviving families – would gain an average of £100,000 each in compensation for negligent exposure to deadly asbestos if the court upholds an earlier 2008 ruling. This found that industrial insurers should pay out on claims relating to the time from which victims are exposed to the deadly fibres.

 

However, insurers appealed the decision. If their appeal is successful, many widows affected face the prospect of no compensation at all. This is because the company the victim worked for no longer exists or because the insurance policy that existed at the time cannot be found.

 

For other victims of asbestos exposure at work, it is simply a case of years of delay while two or more insurers argue about which is liable for compensation. As mesothelioma is such an aggressive cancer, this drawn-out case has meant that almost all of the victims are now dead, leaving their relatives hoping for a ruling in their favour.

 

The Government also stands to lose millions on the outcome of the ruling. If judges rule that insurers do not have to pay out, the Government will face demands for compensation from employees of former nationalised industries and organisations such as the Ministry of Defence.

 

They will also lose out on the thousands of pounds of benefits paid to victims which are clawed back when insurance companies admit liability. Ian McFall, head of asbestos policy at Thompsons solicitors, said: "This is potentially the most important test case in the history of asbestos litigation.

 

For over 50 years it has been the insurer on cover at the time the exposure took place which responds to and pays the claim when someone develops mesothelioma. The insurers now argue that because of the way policies are worded they only apply to the time they got ill.

 

We have hoped and expected that the court would continue to hold insurers liable for policies that were sold to employers at the time workers were being negligently exposed to asbestos."

Hugh Robertson, head of health and safety at the Trades Union Congress, said: "We've been through this so many times with the insurance industry trying to claw back from their moral and legal responsibilities.

 

By continually appealing and drawing out this process as long as possible they're ensuring that victims are never able to put their financial affairs in order before their inevitable death. These tactics are so irresponsible because you're talking about a disease which, on average, results in death just 18 months from diagnosis. This isn't just a tragedy for the families, but for the victims, who are denied even that little peace of mind."

 

If the insurers' appeal is successful, hundreds of firms may be left effectively uninsured to pay for any claims. Experts warn some could be forced out of business if they have to fund compensation themselves.

Some insurers have been embarrassed by the decision to contest the case.

 

A spokesman for the Association of British Insurers admitted: "This is being brought by a small group of run-off insurers against the views of the majority of UK insurers. Most active insurers are happy to pay to people with employers' liability policies."

 

Insurers and victims are expected to appeal to the Supreme Court if they lose, delaying any compensation still further. Tony Whitson, chair of the Asbestos Victims Support Group, said: "Whatever happens, it is likely this will be appealed and go to the Supreme Court. In the meantime, people are dying, their families are trying to cope and insurers are just fighting among themselves with no regard for people."

 

The Independent on Sunday called on the Government last year to stand up to the insurance lobby and ensure proper compensation. Following the campaign, the Labour government pledged a £40m package of measures, including a research centre, support for mesothelioma victims and to investigate an insurance industry-funded compensation scheme for victims whose policies could not be traced. Now the research centre has been put on hold and there is no sign of the Government pursuing insurers for a compensation fund of last resort.

 

Case study: 'I think by the time they decide I won't be here anyway'

 

Frances Grinnell, 78, from Birmingham, is one of thousands of widows who face the prospect of getting no insurance payout at all if the Appeal Court decides that compensation applies only from the moment a victim shows symptoms. Her husband Lawrence died four years ago, aged 74.

 


 


He was diagnosed after the couple had celebrated their golden wedding anniversary. Her husband was exposed to asbestos in the 1950s and 60s while working as a painter and decorator in factories. The painting company he worked for has long since gone out of business; if judges decide the company which then insured them is no longer liable, nobody else will take responsibility.

 

Mrs Grinnell's only job was as a part-time dinner lady and she has no pension from that. If it is ruled that the insurers are liable she has been told she would be awarded £90,000, a sum she says would make a huge difference.

 

"I just keep waiting and waiting to hear. Now I think by the time they decide I won't be here anyway. The money would make life a hell of a lot easier."

 

Case study: 'It's about having someone taking responsibility'

 

Ronald Byrnes died of mesothelioma five years ago, aged 75. He was exposed to asbestos when he worked as a joiner more than 40 years ago. The joinery firm has long since gone out of business, so he hoped compensation would be paid out by their insurance company. His widow, Ann Byrnes, 65, first wrote to the insurers a few months before Ronald died, but as a result of the legal battle they have blocked any payout.

 

They argue they are not liable to pay, as he showed no symptoms of the mesothelioma while he worked at the firm. Now it has been more than five years of waiting as this test case dragged through the courts. The High Court ruled that Mrs Byrnes was owed £100,000 in compensation, but this was put on hold when the appeal was lodged and now it is unclear if she will ever get it.

 

"Insurers have no idea what people go through," she said. "Money isn't going to bring him back, but it's about having someone taking responsibility. The insurance companies are just seeing what they can get away with; they're messing with people's lives.

 

The coroner said if my husband hadn't been exposed to asbestos he would have been expected to live late into his eighties. Someone should pay for what's happening."

 

Check courses available in your area.

Aberdeen Armagh Bangor Bath Belfast Birmingham Bradford Brighton and Hove Bristol Cambridge Canterbury Cardiff Carlisle Chester Chichester City of London Coventry Derby Dundee Durham Edinburgh Ely Exeter Glasgow Gloucester Hereford Inverness Kingston upon Hull Lancaster Leeds Leicester Lichfield Lincoln Lisburn Liverpool Londonderry Manchester Newcastle upon Tyne Newport Newry Norwich Nottingham Oxford Peterborough Plymouth Portsmouth Preston Ripon Salford Salisbury Sheffield Southampton St Albans St Davids Stirling Stoke-on-Trent Sunderland Swansea Truro Wakefield Wells Westminster Winchester Wolverhampton Worcester York Bedfordshire Berkshire Borders Buckinghamshire Cambridgeshire Central Cheshire Cleveland Clwyd Cornwall County Antrim County Armagh County Down County Fermanagh County Londonderry County Tyrone Cumbria Derbyshire Devon Dorset Dumfries and Galloway Durham Dyfed East Sussex Essex Fife Gloucestershire Grampian Greater Manchester Gwent Gwynedd County Hampshire Herefordshire Hertfordshire Highlands and Islands Humberside Isle of Wight Kent Lancashire Leicestershire Lincolnshire Lothian Merseyside Mid Glamorgan Norfolk North Yorkshire Northamptonshire Northumberland Nottinghamshire Oxfordshire Powys Rutland Shropshire Somerset South Glamorgan South Yorkshire Staffordshire Strathclyde Suffolk Surrey Tayside Tyne and Wear Warwickshire West Glamorgan West Midlands West Sussex West Yorkshire Wiltshire Worcestershire Aberaeron Aberdare Aberdeen Aberfeldy Abergavenny Abergele Abertillery Aberystwyth Abingdon Accrington Adlington Airdrie Alcester Aldeburgh Aldershot Aldridge Alford Alfreton Alloa Alnwick Alsager Alston Amesbury Amlwch Ammanford Ampthill Andover Annan Antrim Appleby in Westmorland Arbroath Armagh Arundel Ashbourne Ashburton Ashby de la Zouch Ashford Ashington Ashton in Makerfield Atherstone Auchtermuchty Axminster Aylesbury Aylsham Ayr Bacup Bakewell Bala Ballater Ballycastle Ballyclare Ballymena Ballymoney Ballynahinch Banbridge Banbury Banchory Banff Bangor Barmouth Barnard Castle Barnet Barnoldswick Barnsley Barnstaple Barrhead Barrow in Furness Barry Barton upon Humber Basildon Basingstoke Bath Bathgate Batley Battle Bawtry Beaconsfield Bearsden Beaumaris Bebington Beccles Bedale Bedford Bedlington Bedworth Beeston Bellshill Belper Berkhamsted Berwick upon Tweed Betws y Coed Beverley Bewdley Bexhill on Sea Bicester Biddulph Bideford Biggar Biggleswade Billericay Bilston Bingham Birkenhead Birmingham Bishop Auckland Blackburn Blackheath Blackpool Blaenau Ffestiniog Blandford Forum Bletchley Bloxwich Blyth Bodmin Bognor Regis Bollington Bolsover Bolton Bootle Borehamwood Boston Bourne Bournemouth Brackley Bracknell Bradford Bradford on Avon Brading Bradley Stoke Bradninch Braintree Brechin Brecon Brentwood Bridge of Allan Bridgend Bridgnorth Bridgwater Bridlington Bridport Brigg Brighouse Brightlingsea Brighton Bristol Brixham Broadstairs Bromsgrove Bromyard Brynmawr Buckfastleigh Buckie Buckingham Buckley Bude Budleigh Salterton Builth Wells Bungay Buntingford Burford Burgess Hill Burnham on Crouch Burnham on Sea Burnley Burntisland Burntwood Burry Port Burton Latimer Bury Bushmills Buxton Caernarfon Caerphilly Caistor Caldicot Callander Calne Camberley Camborne Cambridge Camelford Campbeltown Cannock Canterbury Cardiff Cardigan Carlisle Carluke Carmarthen Carnforth Carnoustie Carrickfergus Carterton Castle Douglas Castlederg Castleford Castlewellan Chard Charlbury Chatham Chatteris Chelmsford Cheltenham Chepstow Chesham Cheshunt Chester Chester le Street Chesterfield Chichester Chippenham Chipping Campden Chipping Norton Chipping Sodbury Chorley Christchurch Church Stretton Cinderford Cirencester Clacton on Sea Cleckheaton Cleethorpes Clevedon Clitheroe Clogher Clydebank Coalisland Coalville Coatbridge Cockermouth Coggeshall Colchester Coldstream Coleraine Coleshill Colne Colwyn Bay Comber Congleton Conwy Cookstown Corbridge Corby Coventry Cowbridge Cowdenbeath Cowes Craigavon Cramlington Crawley Crayford Crediton Crewe Crewkerne Criccieth Crickhowell Crieff Cromarty Cromer Crowborough Crowthorne Crumlin Cuckfield Cullen Cullompton Cumbernauld Cupar Cwmbran Dalbeattie Dalkeith Darlington Dartford Dartmouth Darwen Daventry Dawlish Deal Denbigh Denton Derby Dereham Devizes Dewsbury Didcot Dingwall Dinnington Diss Dolgellau Donaghadee Doncaster Dorchester Dorking Dornoch Dover Downham Market Downpatrick Driffield Dronfield Droylsden Dudley Dufftown Dukinfield Dumbarton Dumfries Dunba Dunblane Dundee Dunfermline Dungannon Dunoon Duns Dunstable Durham Dursley Easingwold East Grinstead East Kilbride Eastbourne Eastleigh Eastwood Ebbw Vale Edenbridge Edinburgh Egham Elgin Ellesmere Ellesmere Port Ely Enniskillen Epping Epsom Erith Esher Evesham Exeter ExmouthEye Eyemouth Failsworth Fairford Fakenham Falkirk Falkland Falmouth Fareham Faringdon Farnborough Farnham Farnworth Faversham Felixstowe Ferndown Filey Fintona Fishguard Fivemiletown Fleet Fleetwood Flint Flitwick Folkestone Fordingbridge Forfar Forres Fort William Fowey Framlingham Fraserburgh Frodsham Frome Gainsborough Galashiels Gateshead Gillingham Glasgow Glastonbury Glossop Gloucester Godalming Godmanchester Goole Gorseinon Gosport Gourock Grange over Sands Grangemouth Grantham Grantown on Spey Gravesend Grays Great Yarmouth Greenock Grimsby Guildford Haddington Hadleigh Hailsham Halesowen Halesworth Halifax Halstead Haltwhistle Hamilton Harlow Harpenden Harrogate Hartlepool Harwich Haslemere Hastings Hatfield Havant Haverfordwest Haverhill Hawarden Hawick Hay on Wye Hayle Haywards Heath Heanor Heathfield Hebden Bridge Helensburgh Helston Hemel Hempstead Henley on Thames Hereford Herne Bay Hertford Hessle Heswall Hexham High Wycombe Higham Ferrers Highworth Hinckley Hitchin Hoddesdon Holmfirth Holsworthy Holyhead Holywell Honiton Horley Horncastle Hornsea Horsham Horwich Houghton le Spring Hove Howden Hoylake Hucknall Huddersfield Hungerford Hunstanton Huntingdon Huntly Hyde Hythe Ilford Ilfracombe Ilkeston Ilkley Ilminster Innerleithen Inveraray Inverkeithing Inverness Inverurie Ipswich Irthlingboroug Irvine Ivybridge Jarrow Jedburgh Johnstone Keighley Keith Kelso Kempston Kendal Kenilworth Kesgrave Keswick Kettering Keynsham Kidderminster Kilbarchan Kilkeel Killyleagh Kilmarnock Kilwinning Kinghorn Kingsbridge Kington Kingussie Kinross Kintore Kirkby Kirkby Lonsdale Kirkcaldy Kirkcudbright Kirkham Kirkwall Kirriemuir Knaresborough Knighton Knutsford Ladybank Lampeter Lanark Lancaster Langholm Largs Larne Laugharne Launceston Laurencekirk Leamington Spa Leatherhead Ledbury Leeds Leek Leicester Leighton Buzzard Leiston Leominster Lerwick Letchworth Leven Lewes Leyland Lichfield Limavady Lincoln Linlithgow Lisburn Liskeard Lisnaskea Littlehampton Liverpool Llandeilo Llandovery Llandrindod Wells Llandudno Llanelli Llanfyllin Llangollen Llanidloes Llanrwst Llantrisant Llantwit Major Llanwrtyd Wells Loanhead Lochgilphead Lockerbie Londonderry Long Eaton Longridge Looe Lossiemouth Lostwithiel Loughborough Loughton Louth Lowestoft Ludlow LurganLuton Lutterworth Lydd Lydney Lyme Regis Lymington Lynton Mablethorpe Macclesfield Machynlleth Maesteg Magherafelt Maidenhead Maidstone Maldon Malmesbury Malton Malvern Manchester Manningtree Mansfield March Margate Market Deeping Market Drayton Market Harborough Market Rasen Market Weighton Markethill Markinch Marlborough Marlow Maryport Matlock Maybole Melksham Melrose Melton Mowbray Merthyr Tydfil Mexborough Middleham Middlesbrough Middlewich Midhurst Midsomer Norton Milford Haven Milngavie Milton Keynes Minehead Moffat Mold Monifieth Monmouth Montgomery Montrose Morecambe Moreton in Marsh Moretonhampstead Morley Morpeth Motherwell Musselburgh Nailsea Nailsworth Nairn Nantwich Narberth Neath Needham Market Neston New Mills New Milton Newbury Newcastle Newcastle Emlyn Newcastle upon Tyne Newent Newhaven Newmarket Newport Newport Pagnell Newport on Tay Newquay Newry Newton Abbot Newton Aycliffe Newton Stewart Newton le Willows Newtown Newtownabbey Newtownards Normanton North Berwick North Walsham Northallerton Northampton Northwich Norwich Nottingham Nuneaton Oakham Oban Okehampton Oldbury Oldham Oldmeldrum Olney Omagh Ormskirk Orpington Ossett Oswestry Otley Oundle Oxford Padstow Paignton Painswick Paisley Peebles Pembroke Penarth Penicuik Penistone Penmaenmawr Penrith Penryn Penzance Pershore Perth Peterborough Peterhead Peterlee Petersfield Petworth Pickering Pitlochry Pittenweem Plymouth Pocklington Polegate Pontefract Pontypridd Poole Port Talbot Portadown Portaferry Porth Porthcawl Porthmadog Portishead Portrush Portsmouth Portstewart Potters Bar Potton Poulton le Fylde  Prescot Prestatyn Presteigne Preston Prestwick Princes Risborough Prudhoe Pudsey Pwllheli Ramsgate Randalstown Rayleigh Reading Redcar Redditch Redhill Redruth Reigate Retford Rhayader Rhuddlan Rhyl Richmond Rickmansworth Ringwood Ripley Ripon Rochdale Rochester Rochford Romford Romsey Ross on Wye Rostrevor Rothbury Rotherham Rothesay Rowley Regis Royston Rugby Rugeley Runcorn Rushden Rutherglen Ruthin Ryde Rye Saffron Walden Saintfield Salcombe Sale Salford Salisbury Saltash Saltcoats Sandbach Sandhurst Sandown Sandwich Sandy Sawbridgeworth Saxmundham Scarborough Scunthorpe Seaford Seaton Sedgefield Selby Selkirk Selsey Settle Sevenoaks Shaftesbury Shanklin Sheerness Sheffield Shepshed Shepton Mallet SherborneSheringham Shildon Shipston on Stour Shoreham by Sea Shrewsbury Sidmouth Sittingbourne Skegness Skelmersdale Skipton Sleaford Slough Smethwick Soham Solihull Somerton South Molton South Shields South Woodham Ferrers Southam Southampton Southborough Southend on Sea Southport Southsea Southwell Southwold Spalding Spennymoor Spilsby Stafford Staines Stamford Stanley Staveley Stevenage Stirling Stockport Stockton on Tees Stoke on Trent Stone Stowmarket Strabane Stranraer Stratford upon Avon Strood Stroud Sudbury Sunderland Sutton Coldfield Sutton in Ashfield Swadlincote Swanage Swanley Swansea Swindon Tadcaster Tadley Tain Talgarth Tamworth Taunton Tavistock Teignmouth Telford Tenby Tenterden Tetbury Tewkesbury Thame Thatcham Thaxted Thetford Thirsk Thornbury Thrapston Thurso Tilbury Tillicoultry Tipton Tiverton Tobermory Todmorden Tonbridge Torpoint Torquay Totnes Totton Towcester TredegarTregaron Tring Troon Trowbridge Truro Tunbridge Wells TywynUckfield Ulverston Uppingham Usk Uttoxeter Ventnor Verwood Wadebridge Wadhurst Wakefield Wallasey Wallingford Walsall Waltham Abbey Waltham Cross Walton on Thames Walton on the Naze Wantage Ware Wareham Warminster Warrenpoint Warrington Warwick Washington Watford Wednesbury Wednesfield Wellingborough Wellington Wells Wells next the Sea Welshpool Welwyn Garden City Wem Wendover West Bromwich Westbury Westerham Westhoughton Weston super Mare Wetherby Weybridge Weymouth Whaley Bridge Whitby Whitchurch Whitehaven Whitley Bay Whitnash Whitstable Whitworth Wick Wickford Widnes Wigan Wigston Wigtown Willenhall Wincanton Winchester Windermere Winsford Winslow Wisbech Witham Withernsea Witney Woburn Woking Wokingham Wolverhampton Wombwell Woodbridge Woodstock Wootton Bassett Worcester Workington Worksop Worthing Wotton under Edge Wrexham Wymondham Yarm Yarmouth Yate Yateley Yeadon Yeovil York

 

 

 

Cancer Methoselioma